Pop-Tarts: A "Good Source of 7 Vitamins and Minerals"

As much as I might disagree with highly interventionist policies of public health advocates like Marion Nestle and Michele Simon, I can see exactly where they're coming from when I look at this box of Brown Sugar Cinnamon Pop-Tarts I just bought. Have a look:

No, really. Have a look:

The claim that Pop Tarts are a "good source of 7 vitamins and minerals" is ... what's the word? ...it's coming to me...


But what's extra funny about this claim is, technically, it's true. See for yourself:

By using enriched flour, the food formulators from Battle Creek give you your niacin, iron, vitamin B1 and B2 and folic acid. And then, lower down on the list of ingredients, you can see that they've added some Vitamin B6 and even a little extra Vitamin A, B1 and B2 for good measure. There you go: seven vitamins and minerals. Technically, Pop-Tarts are a "source" of them.

Except that the phrase "good source of" depends on what the meaning of "good" is. Does it mean good as in tastes good? Or good as in good for you? Does good source mean a better source than other foods that also contain these same seven vitamins and minerals? It's all so Clintonian.

Look, I love Pop-Tarts. I don't believe we should ban them, tax them or take them off the shelves. And despite this laughable ad copy, no consumer on Earth should be under the illusion that Pop-Tarts are diet foods, that they're low in sugar, that they'll make you thin if you eat them, or even that they're particularly healthy at all.

But I do have a message for the management at Kellogg's: Don't be jokers. Just sell your product, don't make inadvertently hilarious claims. It's embarrassing.

Related Posts:
When It Comes To Banning Soda, Marion Nestle Fights Dirty
Interview with Jayson Lusk, Author of "The Food Police"
Should I Be Paranoid About Grocery Store Loyalty Cards?
An Interview with "Appetite For Profit" Author Michele Simon

How can I support Casual Kitchen?
Easy. Do all your shopping at Amazon.com via the links on this site! You can also link to me or subscribe to my RSS feed. Finally, consider sharing this article, or any other article you particularly enjoyed here, to Facebook, Twitter (follow me @danielckoontz!) or to bookmarking sites like reddit, digg or stumbleupon. I'm deeply grateful to my readers for their ongoing support.


Michael Goldsman said...

"Good Source of Type 2 Diabetes"

chacha1 said...

@MacMillan bahahaaa!

Pop-Tarts used to be a comfort food for me. But I guess my gradual stepping-down on added sugars finally caught up with them ... the last time I had some they just tasted gross. I am cured!

Anonymous said...

Haha funny post, but technically yes, FDA rules are pretty specific. "Good source of" is a regulated phrase that indicates that food contains 10-19% of your daily value per serving

Rich said...

Came on here to find out what it said there, as they put a sticker over that statement when they import these into the UK!